Friday, January 30, 2009

Task Force on Middle Class Working Families

Sent to Jan 30, 2009 to Vice President Biden via www.strongmiddleclass.gov CC: President Obama (via whitehouse.gov), Senator Dick Durbin, Congresswoman Melissa Bean, Congressman John Boehner (House Minority Leader), Senator Mitch McConnel (Senate Minority Leader), Congressman Steny Hoyer (House Majority Leader), Speaker Pelosi, Senator Harry Reid (Senate Majority Leader)


Dear Vice President Biden,

Congratulations on your appointment to lead the Task Force on Middle Class Working Families.

I too firmly believe that a strong middle class is the only future for America’s long-term prosperity. The middle class is the “consumption engine” of the U.S. economy; therefore there is no hope for sustained economic strength without a strong middle class.

I have been in management roles for the last eight years of my career and I know from first-hand experience that the middle class has been going backwards. A 3% annual raise has not kept up with the cumulative effects of inflation, rising energy prices, rising healthcare costs and rising education costs. The middle class has, indeed, been going backwards.

As you have pointed out, the most recent economic expansion did nothing to help the standing of Middle America. Despite strong productivity increases, record corporate profits, healthy dividends and ballooning executive compensation, the middle class continued to go backward.

This letter addresses four topics: definition of middle class, the productive role of organized labor, supporting the non-union middle class, needed cultural changes within corporate America.

1. Definition of Middle Class
Most politicians talk about the importance of the middle class, but none define what “middle class” means. I feel that the establishment of a working definition of “middle class” is essential for the effective function of your Task Force.

The problem with the term middle class is that is encompasses so many Americans: construction works, law enforcement, sales professionals, middle managers, accountants, factory workers, university professors, journalists, warehouse managers…the list of potential professions and families that comprise the middle class is endless.

This economic classification includes the most, as well as the least educated Americans. The middle class includes Americans with strong upward mobility potential, as well as Americans whose futures look less promising if current career paths are continued. The middle class includes families and individuals who are quite effective at personal/household financial management, as well as individuals and families who live dangerously beyond their means.

For the sake of reasonable policy creation, I believe that a working definition of “middle class” must include a computation of household size and the geographic location of the household. Geographic consideration is an absolute necessity as a reasonable household income in the Chicagoland area (where I live) needs to be considerably higher than the household income of a family living in rural Kansas for example.

Without a reasonable definition of “middle class” no one will know what the Task Force’s discussions and purposes are really about. A definition is also necessary for the transparency you seek to achieve.

2. Productive Role for Organized Labor
In many ways the labor movement and labor unions themselves have gone horribly wrong. Labor unions are businesses just like any other and have gotten greedy and self-interested over the years. The purpose of labor unions, in my opinion, should be to ensure safe and fair working conditions and to promote employment security for its members.

There is an important distinction between job security and employment security that unions (and too many Americans) don’t seem to understand. Many unions, particularly the UAW, have focused on job security and have worked to try to ensure continued pay checks for labor that is no longer needed. Within an environment of global competition, no company can successfully and profitably operate with the burdens of job pools and other mechanisms that do not allow for efficient labor resource management.

A focus on employment security, on the other hand, calls for assuring that workers have current and ever expanding skill sets. A focus on employment security is the difference between having or not having a job and having a career.

Too many Americans and labor unions have focused on having jobs, not on building careers. The skill sets of many Americans are out of date and the reality is that they are not needed in the job market of today. On the other hand, I know of many companies that cannot find workers with the skill sets they now require.

Labor unions have the organizational structure to facilitate the dissemination of continuing education—either directly providing these education services and/or providing the infrastructure for other organizations to provide the needed education.
Labor unions will be relevant and productive in today’s labor market if and only if one of their top priorities is ensuring that their members have the skills needed today—not the skills needed 20-30 years ago.

Labor unions also need to be reasonable. Given ever increasing life expectancies, today’s workers cannot reasonably expect to retire at 48, 58 or 62 with full benefits. No pension system (social security or corporate pensions) was designed to support a 20-30 year retirement. Workers with physically demanding jobs likely cannot perform these jobs as they age. Therefore, unions need to be a key resource and conduit for establishing worker-union-corporation partnerships to redirect workers’ for needed purposes.

Although unions have provided productive outcomes in recent years, the negative light in which managers and executives view unions is much deserved.

I question whether or not you would bristle at the necessity to pay a union electrician (Teamster) $150.00 to plug in a light at McCormick Place in Chicago. No, not skilled electrical wiring that can only safely be done by a licensed electrician—just plugging a light into a power strip. If there is a prayer for organized labor and corporations to have effective partnerships, this kind of nonsense must be forced to stop.

3. Supporting the Non-Union Middle Class
As you well know, there are millions upon millions of non-union middle class Americans. These Americans are also grappling with stagnating and regressing standards of living. The three keys for these Americans, I believe, are fair taxation policies, affordable education and affordable healthcare (these three areas are key for union employees as well).

Within this discussion I would like to focus on education. I believe that it is vital for our pre-school and K-12 education systems to be overhauled in order to assure America’s continued competitiveness on the world stage. The simple fact is that our education system is in disarray, is inefficient/ineffective and we are falling dangerously behind.

Our universities continue to be the envy of the world, but are becoming less and less affordable for many Americans. Without a college education, most of our youth have little chance for a prosperous life. I have an 11-year-old stepson. I recently calculated that it will cost approximately $130,000 to fund his Bachelors degree at the University of Illinois (an in-state school). This is ridiculous. The two questions that surface in my mind are: Are we funding state universities properly AND are state universities managing their money properly with the proper priorities?

Finally, we need affordable adult continuing education programs and education outlets. The world is changing too quickly to permit adults to graduate from high school or college and never step foot in a classroom again. Community colleges can and do fill some of this need, but I believe that this is an issue that needs to be studied carefully. The current programs at many community colleges are part of the answer, but not a complete answer.

4. Needed Cultural Changes in Corporate America
This is the toughest issue to tackle. The reality is that corporate America has become greedy. Attractive quarterly earning statements and annual reports are far more valued that quality corporate management. Corporate America is solely rewarded for today, next month and next quarter. These pressures make good people do really unproductive, and in some cases, bad things.

As a society, we must learn how to celebrate and reward long-term interests and sound business practices. In my view, sound business practices include fair treatment of employees—allowing everyone to enjoy the fruits of a successful team effort.

Vice President Biden, I hope that some of my insights are productive and are considered as you steer the directions of the new Task Force.

I wish you the best of luck on this most important journey.

Sincerely,

Tonia Becker VerShaw
Grayslake, IL
www.toourleaders.blogspot.com

Monday, January 26, 2009

Please Vote No--Digital Television Deadline Extension

Also e-mailed to President Obama and Senator Dick Durbin

Dear Congresswoman Bean,

I am writing to urge you not to vote for extension of the digital television conversion deadline.


1. More than 94% of households in the U.S. are ready for the conversion.

2. If the deadline is extended, what plans are in place to influence or to help the less the 6% who are not ready? If these households have not yet acted, will another four months evoke action?

3. Televisions networks have invested heavily to prepare for this transition. In these times when many networks are struggling (along with so many businesses in general) asking them to operate two transmitters for another four months is unreasonable and in some cases may prompt or contribute to additional layoffs.

4. Television is not a necessity of life. The poor, elderly and others thought to be slow responders to this transition cannot be without food, heat and other life necessities. They can, however, live without a television and a non-operating television will be, possibly, the best catalyst for action.

Congresswoman Bean, you know that these are difficult times for America and many of your constituents. We need to spend our energies and resources fulfilling the true needs of the afflicted. Let’s spend our time, energy and resources to restore our economy and to provide appropriate emergency relief for life’s necessities.

Thank you for your consideration and thank you again for your service to our community and to our nation.

Sincerely,

Tonia Becker VerShaw
Wildwood, IL

cc: President Obama, Senator Durbin

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Economic Recovery Plan Comments

Posted 1/10/208 to http://change.gov/agenda/economy_agenda --"Submit Your Ideas" portion of the site.


Dear President-Elect Obama, Vice President-Elect Biden and Economic Policy Transition Team,


I am excited, hopeful and thankful that such a dedicated and intelligent group has been assembled to lead our nation in these very challenging times.


However, as President-Elect Obama stated within his election night speech, there will be times when we disagree and/or question each other viewpoints. Overall, I believe that the stimulus plan, as currently outlined, is a strong strategy. I strongly believe that infrastructure investment will create jobs and help to get the economy moving again. I love the proposed investments in building the renewable energy industry, education and modernizing healthcare information management.


If managed and structured properly, I believe that these investments will move our nation forward in terms of managing the crisis in the short-term and for long-term prosperity.


In terms of the proposed $3,000 tax credit to businesses for each employee hired, I do not know whether this plan component will work. The arguments on both sides of this issue make sense to me, but I believe that this plan component is worth a try. It may not work, but we cannot progress without some level of experimentation.


I do have strong reservations about the $500 individual, $1,000 family tax credit. This may be a necessary political concession to the Republicans, who as a generalization seem to embrace this type of approach. If this program component is necessary for Republican support to get the rest of the plan through, so be it. However, I strongly question the merit of this program component as it is currently being discussed. Don’t get me wrong, from a selfish standpoint; I will take the gift—what household would not like to have an extra $1,000? However, my household is currently lucky enough to earn a comfortable living, but is below the $200,000 household income level being proposed. I consider us blessed. Frankly, an extra $20.00 in my bi-monthly paycheck is not going to impact my spending habits. As a household, we are not going to rush out with our extra $80.00 per month to buy additional goods or services.


The following are my ideas for reallocating the proposed spending for this portion of the program:


  1. Reduce the household income level qualified to receive the credit and increase the credit to those qualifying households. It is my suspicion that a struggling family of four with a household income of $60,000-$70,000 would benefit from an extra $80.00 - $150.00 per month in their pockets. Republicans are going to scream that this is socialistic income redistribution, so maybe this idea would not work in practicality.

  1. Structure payment of the credit so that it has to spent on goods and services (I see no way for this to work in practicality).

  1. Use the funds in a manner that would help families stay in their homes—restructuring mortgages, etc.

  1. Use these funds to further fund infrastructure, education and renewable energy investments.

I certainly do not have “crystal ball” ideas for improving this crisis, but possibly there is some merit to my thoughts.


Sincerely,


Tonia Becker VerShaw

Grayslake, IL

Please Step Down

E-mailed 12/30/08 (day of the Burris appointment)


Dear Mr. Blagojevich,


As a resident of the great state of Illinois and as a citizen and patriot of the United States of America, I find your conduct absolutely abhorrent. You have lost the respect of your colleagues and have lost the confidence of the citizens of Illinois.


Given the circumstances, I don’t believe that you could possibly be more unfit to serve effectively as Illinois’ Governor.


Within this environment, your appointment of Roland Burris is incredible. Although I believe that President-Elect Obama’s seat could have been filled with a more dynamic individual, I have nothing against Roland Burris. However, the fact that scandal has engulfed you and every decision you now make, makes it impossible for you to fill the vacant Senate seat without serious consequences. I believe that you made this appointment not because you felt it was the best decision for the United States, or the best decision for Illinois. It appears you made this appointment with the same mindset that a child throws a temper tantrum.


Mr. Blagojevich you either have serious psychiatric problems or are one of the largest crooks to ever step foot in the state of Illinois (which is saying a lot). It is my suspicion that you are both delusional and highly crooked. You squandered the gift bestowed upon you by the residents of Illinois—the opportunity to be a truly great leader.


If you had any care at all for the people of Illinois, or the people of the United States of America, you would step aside to allow the process of governing to resume. These are hard times for many Americans. How in these times you, or anyone, can allow our state and our country to become so side-tracked when so many people are in need is beyond me.


If there is a decent bone left in your body, I implore you to step down.


Sincerely,


Tonia Becker VerShaw

Grayslake, IL


**P.S. Please pardon my breech of propriety by addressing you as “Mr.” rather than “Governor.” Given your conduct, I cannot address you with the honorable title of Governor.


cc: President-Elect Barack Obama, Senator Dick Durbin, Congresswoman Melissa Bean, Larry King

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Letter to GM's Chairman/CEO--Richard Wagoner

Letter sent via mail to Richard Wagoner, Chairman/CEO of General Motors and a mailed copy was sent to UAW President, Ron Gettelfinger. Copies of the letter were e-mailed to Congresswoman Melissa Bean, Senator Dick Durbin and President-Elect Barack Obama.


November 30, 2008


G. Richard Wagoner, Jr.
General Motors
300 Renaissance Center
Detroit, MI 48265-3000


Dear Mr. Wagoner,


I certainly do not envy your position. General Motors is in an incredibly challenging and potentially impossible position. Although I am sure that you and your family are not in financial peril, your legacy as a business leader is decidedly at risk. Bold, innovative and thoughtful action will be required.


At the heart of the actions taken there needs to be, in my opinion, an incredible sense of responsibility for GM employees and retirees as well as your suppliers and the American people at large.


You may very well be the first to agree that private businesses requesting Federal assistance is a highly undesirable situation. The private sector should operate responsibly, but without the burdens of oppressive government regulation and without the belief that the tax payers will bail out faulty business management. Our business community and leaders in Washington cannot continue, has it has done for nearly 30 years now, to privatize profit and socialize risk.


There are five topics I have addressed within this letter that I feel have merit for thought—effective product portfolio and customer relations management, operations management, union relationships/union contracts, the pension problem, and the sentiment that select companies are “too big to fail.”


1. Product Portfolio and Customer Relations Management--General Motors has done a poor job, in my opinion, of anticipating market trends and consumer demands. GM put a tremendous amount of the stake in the truck and SUV sectors. Although GM did pretty well in these product areas for a handful of years, not only were many of these vehicles environmentally irresponsible, a dramatic increase in oil/gasoline prices was a highly predictable scenario. No one knew exactly when prices would rise, but operating as if low oil prices would continue forever was extremely short-sighted. Spending enormous amounts of GM time and energies fighting CAFE standards was likewise irresponsible. Could those same resources and energies have been applied to developing fuel efficient technologies? GM is decidedly behind in the development and introduction of fuel efficient vehicles and only time will tell whether or not you are able to catch up and, preferably, be a leader in this arena.


Although I believe that GM’s trucks and SUV’s are perceived to be of high quality by consumers, much of the rest of your product portfolio was and is out of step with consumer trends.


What does America want—a Chevy Cobalt or a Honda Civic? With their pocket books, consumers have voted overwhelmingly for the Honda Civic. Why? Honda has, hands down, done a much better job of creating the perception and the reality that the Civic is a high-quality, stylish, affordable, fun to drive car. I currently owe a 2008 Honda Civic and have driven a Cobalt. The engineering, look and feel of the Civic is simply far superior.


The Buick brand is not perceived to be current—I know few people younger than 80 who drive a Buick. Saturn was an outstanding venture in the early and mid-90’s, but I have no idea what happened.


Another issue that has hurt GM tremendously in the minds of consumers is the general arrogance and lack of care for customers. I owned a 1997 Pontiac Grand Prix. I would be happy to supply the details of the story, but the summary is that at three years and 46,000 miles I had to replace the entire engine in the car. I did replace the engine and drove directly from the Pontiac dealer who did the work to a local Volkswagen dealer. I traded in the Grand Prix before something else went wrong and I bought a Jetta.


I made it clear to the GM personnel I was working with that this situation was not acceptable and that I would never buy another GM car again. This declaration of departure from GM products had no impact. In short, no one cared that as a 28-year-old person (at the time) that I would be purchasing many more cars in my lifetime and that none of them would be GM cars.


Since 2000 when I traded in my Grand Prix I have owned a Volkswagen Jetta, a Volvo and a Honda Civic—all three great cars, but not one from GM’s offerings. I know that I am not alone in feeling betrayed and not appreciated by GM. I would lift my purchase ban on GM products if GM manufactured quality, fuel efficient cars that I want to own and that I had confidence that GM would stand behind the products it sells.


2. Operations Management—It is my understanding that GM’s plants are fairly inflexible in terms of the ability to change out lines and quickly re-purpose a plant to manufacture different products. There is plenty of intelligence from the Japanese on how to implement LEAN manufacturing practices and create flexibility in operations. If your plants truly are inflexible, this is simply inexcusable. If it is true that it is easier and more cost efficient for GM to shutter a plant than to retool it, GM has a very large problem.


3. Union Contracts/Union Relationships—I am certainly not the UAW’s biggest fan. Although I firmly support fair and safe working conditions for all workers and fair wages, the UAW is a business just like any other. It has gotten greedy and self-interested over the years and although has made concessions recently, I fear that these concessions came too little too late. In today’s world, it is not reasonable for workers to be guaranteed pay even if there is not work available. It is not reasonable to put uncompetitive restraints on corporations. Everyone, including the UAW and GM workers will lose.


The admirable historic purpose of unions was to assure that working conditions were safe, fair and that workers were paid fairly, not to negotiate sweet-heart deals for union members that were out of step with the rest of the labor market.


It seems to me that given the seriousness of the situation, third-party mediators might need to become involved. Every line of the UAW/GM contract needs to be reviewed and GM workers will have to accept a situation that is more in line with the reality of today’s business world and stop trying to hang onto 1952 era agreements.


The greatest service that the UAW and other unions could provide to its members, corporations and to the American people is implementing education programs to re-purpose workers as needed. I know that there are a lot of jobs across America which are very difficult to fill because there are not enough people with the current skills to fill the positions.


4. Pension Situation—This is the most difficult problem of them all. At the root of the problem is enormous economic pressure that was only accelerated by the “30 and out” policy negotiated in the early '70's. If a worker started working at GM at 18 and retired at 48 with full benefits, the individual could easily be tapping into the pension for 40 years. The math simply does not work and no pension program was designed for retirement of this longevity.


Maybe a 55 year old is no longer physically able to work on the line. The UAW, GM and individual workers need to partner to re-educate and re-purpose that worker for a less physically demanding, but needed role. The reality is, as more and more of us live into our mid-80’s, 90’s and beyond, we have to figure out ways to be productive members of society longer. Non-UAW workers, including myself, will be working into their late 60’s and early 70’s. GM workers need to follow suit.


5. “Too Big to Fail”—The following is a segment from a letter I wrote to my Congresswoman, Melissa Bean, and to my Senator, Dick Durbin.


If we have corporations that are truly “too big to fail,” perhaps corporations should not be allow to get that big. Or, at least not allowed to become “too big” without adequate capital and liquidity to navigate through economic downturns. I have no idea how this idea could be structured in a way that supports fair free-markets (emphasis on fair), yet protects the American economy from a handful of companies bringing our entire economy to its knees. Although, I have no idea how this idea could be structured, I do believe that there is merit to the thought.


Mr. Wagoner, I truly hope that you will take my thoughts and insights into consideration. There is nothing I would like more than to have a thriving U.S. auto industry, but it is clear that General Motors, Chrysler nor Ford can continue to operate as they have for now decades.


Sincerely,


Tonia Becker VerShaw



Saturday, November 29, 2008

Bailout Management

Sent to Congresswoman Melissa Bean and Senator Dick Durbin, November 13, 2008


First I would like to congratulate you on your re-election. With the re-election of you and Dick Durbin, as well as the election of President-Elect Obama, election night was a thrilling evening.


During this campaign season I made the promise to myself to become more involved in our democracy. One of the greatest privileges Americans enjoy is the ability to contact our elected officials with our opinions, concerns and praise. Therefore, you will be hearing from me on a regular basis.


This being said, I am quite concerned about the execution path of the bailout bill. I believe I share the views of many Americans. In my opinion, the need to pass the bailout bill was a highly undesirable position, but necessary given the circumstances.


From my understanding, the bill called for active congressional oversight. This oversight does not appear to be happening. The situation is starting to carry the "stench" of much of the rest of the Bush years--do what we want and there is no need to keep the American people informed of our decision-making process, no need to tell anyone what we are actually doing.


This is entirely unacceptable and I ask that you do what you can to speak out in opposition to the situation.


Granted, the financial dilemma America faces is highly complex. Despite being a relatively sharp person, I can't even pretend to understand all of the complexities. It is probably safe to say that very few really have the background and the knowledge to have solid insight on the situation.


I can say with reasonable deal of certainty that I do not support bailout funds being used to fund acquisition activity, to fund employee (especially top executive) bonuses, nor to prop up shareholder dividends. This being said, if non-partisan experts believe in good judgment that it is appropriate to use bailout funds for the above mentioned purposes, I would want objective information as to why supporting these activities will help our overall economic situation.


The Bush administration has continually supported measures that allow money to swirl at a frenetic pace at the very top levels of our economy. The last eight years have almost been like the richest 3% of our population has been standing in a giant money booth (like you sometimes see at the fair)--money swirling around and this top 3% stuffing money in their pockets as fast as possible. However, the "money booth" of the last eight years contained monetary denominations much larger that one dollar bills.


$700 billion is a great deal of money and it cannot continue to be spent with Congress and the American people sitting in the dark. The stakes are just too high.


On another note, I have very mixed feelings about the prospects of bailing out the American auto industry. In recent times, the big three have been three of the most poorly managed companies in our economy. Should this poor management be rewarded without very core changes in operation? We will be in the same situation a year or two from now. On the other hand, can we afford to lose the hundreds of thousands of jobs attached directly and indirectly to the US auto industry right now? I don't know.


This also needs to be a public dialog backed by objective, smart, non-partisan information.

I would like to leave you with two final thoughts. One of the positive results of the mess that our country has inflicted on ourselves is that I am one of millions giving active thought as to how we can correct our current challenges. The following two thoughts are simple and maybe are obvious, but maybe there is some truth shrouded in simplistic notions.


  1. We cannot allow corporate America to continue to privatize profit and socialize risk. The Wall Street that lobbies actively for deregulation and laissez-faire practices when times are good is the same Wall Street that is streaming to Capitol Hill with hats in hand. We cannot have it both ways and expect that our country will prosper.

  1. If we have corporations that are truly “too big to fail,” perhaps corporations should not be allow to get that big. Or, at least not allowed to become “too big” without adequate capital and liquidity to navigate through economic downturns. I have no idea how this idea could be structured in a way that supports fair free-markets (emphasis on fair), yet protects the American economy from a handful of companies bringing our entire economy to its knees. Although, I have no idea how this idea could be structured, I do believe that there is merit to the thought.


Continued success as you head into your new term. We have many, many challenges before us. But, I feel confident that we can overcome them if politics is pushed aside and we all work to do what is best for the long-term health of our nation as well as to address the short-term crisis.


Sincerely,

Tonia Becker VerShaw

Dear President-Elect Obama

Sent week of November 15, 2008.


Dear President-Elect Obama and Transition Team,


Like many Americans, I am excited and a bit anxious about the days to come. Our country, as you know better than any other set of Americans, has decided challenges. One hates to say that our country is a mess, but I don't know that softer sentiments describe our current condition or the road ahead.


I trust President-Elect Obama's ability, talent, dedication, intelligence and integrity much more than that of any other elected official in my lifetime. However, I do not desire to put the fate of my country, my future and our children's future solely in the hands of our elected officials in Washington any longer. Americans have been disengaged from our political system for way, way too many years...look where it has gotten us. We cannot turn a blind eye any longer.


Americans across our land must peacefully and respectfully stand up and say, "no more."


How do we accomplish this utilizing that incredible strong grassroots network created during the campaign season? I am flatly apposed to movements that encourage people to stand on street corners yelling and screaming. How can we organize to communicate respectfully and meaningfully with our leaders outside of campaign seasons?


How can we create a culture in which our elected officials speak to American citizens in calm, thoughtful, honest manners without being so concerned if a given statement fits news bite/sound bite formulas?


I, along with I believe millions of other Americans, do not want to be pacified with rhetoric, we don't want to be deceived and we want a voice in the directions and decisions of our government. Solely making the voices of everyday Americans heard on election days is not enough. We can all see where the separation of government from the governed has taken us.


I will look forward to your reply in some format and am willing to do whatever I can to help. I want my country back.


Sincerely,

Tonia Becker VerShaw